Carmine Falcone and his slow nephew John Viti (reimagined as a Johnny Sack-esque underboss, played by Michael Kelly, in “The Penguin”) first appeared in Frank Miller and David Mazzucchelli’s “Batman: Year One.” However, “The Long Halloween” is the book that defined the Falcone and his place in Batman mythos.
Loeb and Sale decided to complete the bridge that “Year One” built, showing how Gotham’s old mafiosos got displaced by the supervillain freaks. So, they brought back Falcone and introduced his children: Sofia and Alberto. Mazzucchelli had already drawn Carmine looking a bit like Marlon Brando as Vito Corleone, so Sale leaned into that. (The big physical difference is that Carmine has three claw scars on his cheek, a gift from Selina Kyle.)
In “The Long Halloween,” Alberto is modeled on Fredo Corleone (John Cazale); he’s sullen, unmasculine, and the family black sheep, not a cocky alcoholic like the Chris-Ta-Fuh lite version in “The Penguin.” Sofia is played by Cristin Miloti in “The Penguin.” Like the comic, she’s ruthless, violent, and short-tempered, but Milioti is small and waifish. Comic Sofia is tall and burly; her temper and build have gotten her described as a female Sonny Corleone (James Caan). Loeb and Sale’s sequel, “Batman: Dark Victory,” completed the triptych by introducing Mario Falcone, Carmine’s once-exiled son, and a Michael Corleone (Al Pacino) analog.
It’s not just the mob family dynamics that “Long Halloween” takes from “The Godfather,” though. The series opens with Bruce Wayne attending a wedding held by the Falcones. While in Carmine’s office, he declares, “I believe in Gotham City.”Â
DC Comics
The homage has a deeper meaning (Batman’s whole purpose is to save the soul of his corrupted city), but the influence of “The Godfather” couldn’t be more obvious.
In “The Long Halloween” issue #9, gangster Sal Maroni visits his retired father Luigi for advice, who tells him “You can act like a man!” — the same angry advice Vito Corleone gave Johnny Fontane (Al Martino). As Luigi picks tomatoes from his garden (Gregory Wright’s coloring makes the fruit look almost orange), he’s shot by the unseen Holiday killer.
