“Browns are setting up Shedeur Sanders to FAIL!”
— on the decision to start rookie QB Shedeur Sanders in the Cleveland Browns’ preseason opener
📝 What Michael Irvin Mean by That
- Tough Circumstances for a Rookie Starter
- The Browns listed Sanders as the fourth-string quarterback, behind veterans Joe Flacco and Kenny Pickett, plus rookie Dillon Gabriel, who has since been injured. With limited first-team reps, he’s being thrown into the deep end with little preparation. The Times of India+15YouTube+15TikTok+15Yahoo Sports+15Reuters+15The Sun+15
- Expectation vs. Reality
- Despite high college expectations and falling to the fifth round of the draft, Sanders hasn’t received the same developmental investment. Irvin sees this as a mismatch between expectation and support. Reddit+1New York Post+3Reuters+3New York Post+3
- Limited Preseason Opportunity
- Starting a rookie with minimal practice time and no consistent reps with the first team is risky—it could damage confidence or derail growth if mistakes happen early. This is what Irvin argues: a recipe for failure.
📊 What’s Actually Going On
| Factor | Status |
|---|---|
| Preseason Start | Sanders confirmed to start opener vs. Panthers |
| Depth Chart | Currently listed as fourth-string QB |
| Injuries | Pickett & Gabriel sidelined, opening slot |
| Development Plan | Sanders has yet to take first-team snaps, but will split time with Tyler Huntley |
| Public Narrative | Owner Haslam distanced himself; Sanders pushing through adversity |
- The Browns officially plan to start Sanders in the preseason opener. Despite lack of reps, he has a chance to shine due to injuries in the QB room. AOL+15Reuters+15The Sun+15New York Post+1Reddit+3Talksport+3Talksport+3
- Browns owner Jimmy Haslam has publicly stated he was surprised by the pick and made it clear it was GM Andrew Berry’s call—not his own. Sanders has since impressed during camp, completing 42 of 60 passes with 5 TDs and 0 INTs early on. The Sun+15Talksport+15Dawgs By Nature+15
- That said, Cleveland radio host Ken Carman defended the organization, saying the team is not deliberately undermining Sanders and that he is being given a fair evaluation. Talksport+15Talksport+15New York Post+15
🧠 Context Around Shedeur
- Shedeur Sanders is a rookie QB drafted in the fifth round (Pick 144) despite first-round projections. In college, he earned high praise and awards under his father Deion Sanders. Facebook+15Wikipedia+15Reuters+15
- He’s displayed maturity—asking his father not to attend training camp to avoid distractions, citing limited reps and preferring to earn visibility on merit. Deion Sanders shared this during a conversation with Michael Irvin. Facebook+4Reddit+4Talksport+4
🎯 Takeaway: Is Irvin Right?
- Yes, in that starting a rookie with little prep and depth behind him can feel like a setup for failure. The organizational messaging and depth chart suggest limited investment so far.
- No, in that the team is giving Sanders opportunities to earn playing time, and he has performed well statistically in early camp—with some insiders expressing optimism about his potential. TalksportDawgs By Nature
Would you like me to break down what to expect from Sanders in preseason performance, or analyze how his skills compare to the veteran QBs on the roster?
Sources
Ask ChatGPT